Navy Hairbrella swim cap with adjustable strap and thank-you card on a wood surface

I swim almost every day, and it’s hard on my hair. So when I found a satin-lined swim cap that promised to keep my hair dry, I was ready to put it to the test. Could the Hairbrella finally be the cap that let me enjoy my daily swim without soaking my hair?

For this Hairbrella swim cap review, I tried the Classic size, exchanged it for the Classic Sport, and took it back into the pool for another round of testing. There were things I really liked, especially the comfort and customer service, but my underwater swims told a different story.

*I purchased the Hairbrella myself. This is an independent review, no compensation was provided and I am not an affiliate.

What Is the Hairbrella Swim Cap?

The Hairbrella swim cap combines a waterproof exterior with a smooth satin lining and an adjustable band. A clasp at the back lets you fasten the cap and tighten the straps for a closer fit. Hairbrella markets it as a way to protect your hair and keep it dry, including underwater.

The satin lining was a big part of the appeal for me. I wanted something that felt comfortable without tugging at my hair, and I liked the idea of a cap designed with hair care in mind.

Hairbrella swim cap packaging showing the satin-lined adjustable cap
Close-up of the Hairbrella swim cap clasp and adjustable strap

Picking Out My Hairbrella

I initially chose the popular Classic size in a pretty metallic blue. It arrived in just a couple of days, which impressed me right away.

Hairbrella offers several sizes, including Classic, Classic Sport, XL, XL Sport and Kids. The Hairbrella size guide and fitting tutorial explains how the options differ. Here are the measurements listed in that guide:

SizeHead CircumferenceCap Depth
Classic17–22 inches13 inches
Classic Sport (Sport)17–22 inches11 inches
XL20–24 inches16 inches
XL Sport20–24 inches12 inches
Kids15–19 inches9 inches

The Classic and Sport options share the same listed head-circumference range, but the Sport is shallower. That difference in how much room sits above your head became especially relevant during my first swim.

Blue Hairbrella Classic swim cap with water droplets on poolside pavers
My first cap was the Classic size in metallic blue.

My First Hairbrella Test Swim

The cap came with instructions that I found easy to follow. Once I had it on, the fit was tight but not too uncomfortable, and it wasn’t pulling at my hair. It felt much better than other swim caps I’d tried.

At first, I swam back and forth with my head above the water. The cap stayed in place and kept my hair dry. So far, so good!

Candy Keane wearing a blue Hairbrella swim cap beside the pool
Trying the Hairbrella in the pool.

Then I went for a deep dive, and my swim cap turned into a balloon. It filled with air, puffed up around my head, and made it difficult to get very far underwater. My big balloon head was keeping me afloat.

I suspected there was too much extra room inside the cap for my head and hair. Rather than giving up after the first attempt, I decided to try a different size.

Exchanging the Classic for the Classic Sport

I went back to the website and arranged an exchange for the Classic Sport swim cap in the same blue. I hoped the shallower fit would help with the extra space.

If I were rating the customer service alone, I’d give it five stars. The exchange was fast and easy, communication was excellent, and the replacement arrived quickly, just like my first order.

Even though the product ultimately didn’t work the way I wanted, I appreciated how smoothly the company handled the exchange.

Hairbrella Classic Sport swim cap in metallic blue with product tag
The Classic Sport cap I tried next.

My Second Hairbrella Test Swim

For round two, I paid extra attention to the fit. I made sure the cap was good and tight and left my ears outside, as the instruction card recommended. I also pressed out the trapped air so the cap sat smoothly against my head.

Hairbrella instruction card illustrating how to fit and tighten the swim cap
Hairbrella swim cap held to show its clasp and adjustable band

When I went underwater, it didn’t balloon up this time. We were off to a much better start.

I swam back and forth underwater, but after a few minutes I could feel water seeping in. I wanted this to work so badly! When I checked my hair, it was wet underneath and around my hairline.

Candy Keane showing wet hair after testing the Hairbrella swim cap in the pool
My hair was wet underneath and around the hairline after swimming underwater.

I gave it another try the next day. Unfortunately, I got the same result: my hair was wet after less than five minutes of swimming underwater.

Did the Hairbrella Keep My Hair Dry?

For me, the answer depended on how I was swimming. During my initial above-water swim, it stayed in place and kept my hair dry. Once I spent time underwater, it didn’t keep the water out.

Switching from Classic to Classic Sport solved the ballooning problem in my next test, but it didn’t solve the leaking. Even after tightening the fit, leaving my ears out and pressing out the air, I still ended up with wet hair.

My Final Thoughts on Hairbrella

Unfortunately, the Hairbrella satin-lined swim cap wasn’t the magical solution I’d hoped for. I wanted to swim underwater and come out with dry hair, and that didn’t happen in my tests.

That said, I’ve never found a swim cap that has worked perfectly for me. Maybe it’s my head shape, my hair, the fit, or some combination of those things. Everyone’s head is different, and my experience doesn’t mean yours will be identical.

Based on my above-water test, I can see it being more useful for someone who generally keeps their head out of the water. I’d be more cautious about expecting completely dry hair during repeated underwater swimming.

I did like the comfortable feel, the lack of hair pulling and the pretty blue color. And the customer service deserves credit: the company made trying another size easy. For my daily underwater swims, though, I’m still looking for a cap that keeps my hair dry.

Hairbrella has more than just swim caps. They also have sleeping bonnets and rain caps, which probably work better than the swim caps. The make a quality product (even if it didn’t work for me) and have great customer service.

Check out their website at: https://www.hairbrella.com


Discover more from The Midnight Pumpkin Blog

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

One response to “Hairbrella Swim Cap Review: Did It Keep My Hair Dry?”

  1. […] rinse water comfortably cool. If swimming is part of your routine, you might want to try wearing a swim cap, and always rinse your hair immediately when getting out of the […]

Leave a Reply

I’m Candy

Welcome to Midnight Pumpkin, my cozy little corner of the internet dedicated to fantastical fashion, beauty and cosplay.

Let’s connect